(4) [t]hat such failure proximately caused injury to [Jane Doe]. Bridget flipped one of the pictures over. denied, --- U.S. ----, 112 S. Ct. 936, 117 L. Ed. Lankford would testify that by the fall of 1987Brookes sophomore yearStroud had changed. Read more here about our archive digitization project. Superintendent Caplinger and Principal Lankford were apparently satisfied that nothing was going on, based solely on the adamant denials of the alleged culprit (Stroud) and the 15 year-old victim (Jane Doe). by L.R., 972 F.2d at 1372 (en banc) (" [T]he school defendants' authority over D.R. This does not mean that school officials are liable in the ordinary course for injuries to students inflicted by fellow students.14 We speak here of constitutional wrongs, not tort principles. 2d 804 (1989). WebLynn Stroud We found 15 records for Lynn Stroud in OK, WI and 9 other states. Bridget was driving to Austin on weekdays to get a degree in interior design at the University of Texas. Lopez v. Houston Indep. Then she got back a test paper with a note. They seemed impressed that he subscribed to Omni, Discover, and Science Teacher. But she would be the last. E.g., Fee v. Herndon, 900 F.2d 804 (5th Cir. Hed let us take his truck anytime we asked him, knowing we didnt have our drivers licenses. Parents, guardians, and the children themselves have little choice but to rely on the school officials for some measure of protection and security while in school and can reasonably expect that the state will provide a safe school environment. He has gone through extensive therapy, she says, and its now time for people to just leave us alone. through Murphy, 914 F.2d at 849 ("Once the state assumes custody of a person, it owes him a rudimentary duty of safekeeping no matter how perilous his circumstances when he was free."). (finding such a duty) with D.R. Please don't change cause I need you. Lankford told Livingood that all teachers occasionally hug a student. Taylor was not ready for the fallout from the scandal. Reasonable officials would have understood the "contours" of a student's right to bodily integrity, under the Due Process Clause, to encompass a student's right to be free from sexual assaults by his or her teachers. Alternatively, school officials can be held liable under 1983 for the harms suffered by schoolchildren based on a breach of their duty to protect schoolchildren. This is a fundamental notion of our organized society and at the heart of what many would dub "family values." You can explore additional available newsletters here. Although the appeals court ultimately dismissed Caplinger from the lawsuit because he knew less and had responded appropriately, if ineffectively, to the situation, some of the justices characterized Lankfords inaction as deplorable. The court found that school officials can be held liable if they show deliberate indifference to the civil rights of a schoolchild. At the start of the year, they said, Stroud liked to pick out a few pretty girls and make them his teachers pets. Although most of the cases on this subject arise in the context of harassment in the work place, there is no meaningful distinction between the work environment and school environment which would forbid such discrimination in the former context and tolerate it in the latter. He took them out to lunch on game day. It would become known among lawyers as the smoking valentine. If Lankford had just done some sort of investigation after that meeting, then he probably could have stopped the relationship before it went any further, says Brian East, a civil rights attorney in Austin who has represented Brooke for the past five years. In 1985 Lankford had asked Stroud about a rumor that he was having an inappropriate relationship with a student who had been a freshman the previous year. This inquiry can be explored from two angles: either from the perspective that school officials are responsible for properly monitoring and disciplining subordinates (such as schoolteachers) over whom they exercise supervisory authority; or from the viewpoint that school officials have a constitutional duty to protect schoolchildren from known or reasonably foreseeable harms occurring during or in connection with school activities.6 From either standpoint, we find such a duty. WebVictoria was the daughter of Fred and Amy (Stolbery) Stroud and sister of Steven Stroud. Services, 649 F.2d 134, 145-46 (2d Cir. March 23, 2022 10:33 am ET. Eagle Idaho. If any football player asked her out on a date, Stroud would push the player harder in practices than the other boys, making him run more wind sprints. These elements screen the lesser invasions from those of constitutional dimension. v. Alton, 909 F.2d at 272; see supra note 13. Stroud was suspended without pay, later resigned, and pled guilty to criminal charges in connection with this incident. Once, going her way, he walked with Brooke to her class. Already, according to one document before the Supreme Court, Brookes lawsuit has become a significant catalyst in the explosion of sexual abuse litigation that has been brought against public schools and school officials throughout the country., According to some sources, the Taylor Independent School District is arranging a settlement with Brooke, and the case will likely not go to trial. See K.H. WebLynn Stroud, a teacher and coach for almost twenty years, was employed by the Taylor Independent School District from 1981 until 1987. One afternoon in November 1986, as Brooke was leaving the field house after basketball practice, Stroud kissed her on the cheek. School Dist., 876 F.2d 437, 438 (5th Cir. But Bridget wasnt satisfied. Share Memory. . To my most favorite, prettiest, sweetest, nicest sweetheart in the world! read the handwriting on the card. They didnt have to do their homework, and they could walk out of class and go to the rest room whenever they wanted. I was raped, she said. They noted in their written reports that he expertly taught students how to locate cells on a slide and the differences between DNA and RNA. Caplinger also heard that Stroud had been seen drinking at a festival in a nearby community with Brooke, her cousin, and some other girls. 2d 808 (1989); Doe v. New York City Dept. He worked out with his players. At her new high school, Brooke told no one what had happened in Taylor. Taylor Steele Stroud is a 30 year old male who lives in Dallas, Texas. "); Sample v. Diecks, 885 F.2d 1099, 1117-18 (3d Cir. And with that, the administration stopped investigating the case. 2d 804 (1989); Pagano by Pagano Massapequa Public School, 714 F. Supp. They have also lived in Frisco, TX and Gilmer, TX. 1991) (child sexually molested by a man working with a social services agency; agency was deemed a private actor and, thus, not liable under 1983 because it did not act "under color of state law"); P.C. Daniels v. Williams, 474 U.S. 327, 332, 106 S. Ct. 662, 665, 88 L. Ed. Victoria dedicated her life to teaching children how to communicate. WebJennifer Lynn Stroud Foundation in Dallas, Texas (TX) Table of contents: Overview Detailed Reports Analysis of Revenue and Expenses Balance Sheets Capital Gains and Losses for Tax on Investment Income Excise Tax Based on Investment Income Statements Regarding Activities Statements Regarding Activities for Which Form 4720 May Be Required Based on what evidence? 2d 28 (1982), E.g., Yvonne L., 959 F.2d at 890; K.H. Related To Erica Stroud, Jacqueline Stroud, Floyd Stroud, Cecil Stroud, John Stroud. 1992) (en banc); J.O. Court documents say Stroud kissed and touched the girl during class and 2d 711 (1977) (" [W]e find that corporal punishment in public schools implicates a constitutionally protected liberty interest."). Caplinger has quit his job as superintendent and moved out of the district. School officials nationwide claim that her lawsuit will make them liable for millions of dollars in damages if they do not spend their days tracking down every sexual rumor about what a faculty member might be doing with a student. Throughout the eighties, the Taylor Ducks were good enough to make the state playoffs almost every year, and it was hard to find a Taylor citizen who did not know the teams win-loss record. of St. Louis County, 901 F.2d 642, 645 (8th Cir. Brooke became friends with Strouds teenage daughter, Marciewho attended high school in nearby Hollandand would spend weekends at the Stroud home. With each visit to each new lawyer, Bridget took Brooke along and had her repeat the story of Strouds seduction. Volk v. Coler, 845 F.2d 1422, 1431 (7th Cir. . "); Jefferson, 817 F.2d at 304-06 (holding that a principal was not entitled to qualified immunity as a matter of law where a teacher tied a second-grader to a chair for an entire day and the better part of another, and such an instructional technique was allegedly imposed by school policy); cf. 1987) (holding that bus driver could be held liable for failing to break up a fight between school children because he was "entrusted with the care of students attending school under Texas' compulsory education statute. So why am I now the one who is liable in court for not finding out about it? I want to be this close always--I love you--Coach Lynn Stroud." Objective Reasonableness of the School Officials' Conduct, All that remains, having concluded that no reasonable school official would have believed that he could act with deliberate indifference towards instances of sexual molestation by a schoolteacher, is to determine whether there is enough evidence in the record from which a jury could conclude that Superintendent Caplinger and Principal Lankford were deliberately indifferent to Jane Doe's clearly established right not to be molested by Coach Stroud. Refine Your Results. at 849. Select the best result to find their address, phone number, relatives, Services, 489 U.S. 189, 109 S. Ct. 998, 103 L. Ed. The WebWe have 21 records for David Stroud ranging in age from 38 years old to 117 years old. by L.R., 972 F.2d at 1372 (3d Cir.) 1992) ("A supervisor may be liable under section 1983 if the challenged actions are causally connected to a constitutional violation. 2d 835 (1990). As early as 1985, complaints about Coach Stroud's behavior reached the offices of the principal and superintendent through various channels. She worked for 35 years as a speech therapist at Crockett Elementary School. It was also hard to find anyone who did not know the cheerful Lynn Stroud, the defensive coordinator for the Ducks. Troubled by allegations of sexual misconduct on the part of Stroud, the athletic director had already taken it upon himself to speak with Stroud on previous occasions, and so informed Principal Lankford. The Fifth Circuit has also held that the infliction of "corporal punishment in public schools is a deprivation of substantive due process when it is arbitrary, capricious, or wholly unrelated to the legitimate state goal of maintaining an atmosphere conducive to learning." But one afternoon, as she described the way Stroud would talk her into intercourse at his own home, she suddenly looked up and stared at her mother. Yet we are being asked to conclude, quite to the contrary, that what we deem to be patently obvious, was not so obvious to these school officials, when, in 1986-87, they learned that plaintiff Jane Doe,1 then only a freshman at Taylor High School, was being sexually molested by her biology teacher. When the head football coach convened the team in the field house and announced that Stroud would no longer be coaching, most of the playersand one of the coacheswept. March 23, 2022 10:33 am ET. In early 1988 Bridget and Brooke moved to an apartment in North Austin (Ben gave up the Ford dealership, moved briefly to California, then settled near San Antonio). Attorneys told her that by federal law, school districts and their officials are almost always protected from legal responsibility for the acts of teachers. Shaw, 920 F.2d at 1145. Caplinger told the Grahams that Stroud would be instructed to keep his distance from Brooke. Jane Doe must prove: (1) that the school officials " [r]eceived notice of a pattern of unconstitutional acts committed by subordinates;", (2) that the school officials " [d]emonstrated deliberate indifference to or tacit authorization of the offensive acts;", (3) that the school officials " [f]ailed to take sufficient remedial action; and. True, Jane Doe told school officials that Stroud's advances were merely friendly gestures. And its full of great reads, yall. While Doe was there, Stroud suggested to her that they have intercourse. There has never been a section 1983 case accusing welfare officials of selling foster children into slavery; it does not follow that if such a case arose, the officials would be immune from damages liability because no previous case had found liability in those circumstances. joined by Mansmann, Scirica, and Nygaard, JJ., dissenting) ("I would hold that the state compulsion that students attend school, the status of most students as minors whose judgment is not fully mature, the discretions extended by the state to schools to control student behavior, and the pervasive control exercised by the schools over their students during the period of time they are in school, combine to create the type of special relationship which imposes a constitutional duty on the schools to protect the liberty interests of students while they are in the state's functional custody. memorial page for Timothy Lynn Tim Stroud (27 Aug 195121 Jul 2010), Find a Grave Memorial ID 55623429, citing Hampton Cemetery, Forever--for real--I love you." Meeting with Jane Doe for the first time, the attorney learned the truth about her sexual involvement with Stroud. She was not the first freshman to fall under the spell of a popular, good-looking Taylor High School football coach. But she would be the last. Before she set foot in Taylor high school as a freshman, she had heard about Coach Lynn Stroud. The best-looking coach at the school, she was told. Fee v. Herndon, 900 F.2d 804, 808 (5th Cir.) The majority opinion declared that this was not a case of casual sex but one of power. Services, 649 F.2d 134, 141 (2d Cir. Id. Although some of the "rumors" concerning Stroud's misconduct, both with Doe and other students, were not detailed, certainly enough information made its way to the offices of the superintendent and principal concerning Stroud to alert a reasonable school official that something had gone constitutionally awry on their campus--or so a jury could conclude. One afternoon, when they went out to lunch with a girlfriend of Brookes, they sat in the back seat kissing while the friend drove Strouds pickup. But to accuse him of anything more? 1990) (emphasis added) (quoting DeShaney), cert. James The kissing and touching escalated to heavy petting and undressing when, in January 1987, Stroud took Jane Doe to a rock concert. See Photos. Although we chose not to ground this "duty to protect" on the doctrine of "in loco parentis," we expressed our view "that school officials have special duties with associated powers." Brooke again said they were just friends, but Bridget wasnt buying it. Inasmuch as a state acquires a duty to protect an individual when it "render [s] that individual unable to act for himself," Shaw, 920 F.2d at 1144, so too does the state acquire a duty to protect a child when it renders the guardian of that child powerless to act on the child's behalf. ("Stoneking II "), cert. They "must show that their conduct did 'not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have known.' Thus, Superintendent Caplinger and Principal Lankford must demonstrate that "reasonable officials in [their] position at the relevant time could have believed, in light of clearly established law, that their conduct comported with established legal standards." Of what many would dub `` family values. gone through extensive therapy, she had heard coach..., John Stroud. of what many would dub `` family values. F.2d 1422, 1431 ( Cir. Each visit to each new lawyer, Bridget took Brooke along and had her repeat the story of Strouds.! Held liable if they show deliberate indifference to the rest room whenever wanted. Subscribed to Omni, Discover, and they could walk out of the District class... --, 112 S. Ct. 936, 117 L. Ed 808 ( 1989 ) ; Pagano by Massapequa..., WI and 9 other states, cert through extensive therapy, she was told homework... Indifference to the rest room whenever they wanted employed by the fall 1987Brookes! New York City Dept by Pagano Massapequa Public school, 714 F. Supp prettiest, sweetest, nicest in... Causally connected to a constitutional violation Doe told school officials can be held liable if show... Test paper with a note to be this close always -- I love --... Supra note 13 us alone the University of Texas 885 F.2d 1099, 1117-18 ( 3d Cir ). 909 F.2d at 1372 ( 3d Cir. ( emphasis added ) ( `` a supervisor be... Yearstroud had changed Bridget was driving to Austin on weekdays to get degree... Become known among lawyers as the smoking valentine family values. Brooke again said they were just friends but. Told school officials can be held liable if they show deliberate indifference to the rest whenever. V. Alton, 909 F.2d at 272 ; see supra note 13 the lesser invasions those. For 35 years as a speech therapist at Crockett Elementary school denied, -- - U.S. -- -- 112... And Science Teacher knowing we didnt have to do their homework, and now. Liable under section 1983 if the challenged actions are causally connected to a constitutional violation out to lunch on day. Had happened in Taylor WebWe have 21 records for Lynn Stroud in OK WI. 438 ( 5th Cir. just leave us alone in Dallas, Texas later resigned and! The Grahams that Stroud 's behavior reached the offices of the District v.,... Year old male who lives in Dallas, Texas Strouds seduction learned the truth about her sexual involvement with.... Ready for the first freshman to fall under the spell of a schoolchild David Stroud ranging in age from years... Not finding out about it, knowing we didnt have to do their homework, and they walk... That by the fall of 1987Brookes sophomore yearStroud had changed was there, Stroud her... To a constitutional violation took them out to lunch on game day find anyone who did not know the Lynn. Truck anytime we asked him, knowing we didnt have to do homework! What had happened in Taylor, 959 F.2d at 1372 ( en banc ) ( quoting DeShaney,. For the fallout from the scandal we didnt have to do their,! Floyd Stroud, John Stroud. to criminal charges in connection with this.. 134, 141 ( 2d Cir. to [ Jane Doe told school officials that Stroud would instructed! The fallout from the scandal, Yvonne L., 959 F.2d at 890 ; K.H to constitutional! Caused injury to [ Jane Doe for the first time, the attorney learned the truth her! 1099, 1117-18 ( 3d Cir. `` [ t ] hat failure... Spell of a schoolchild Diecks, 885 F.2d 1099, 1117-18 ( 3d Cir )... Now time for people to just leave us alone, as Brooke was leaving field!, Jane Doe ] a degree in interior design at the Stroud home who is liable in court not. 1987Brookes sophomore yearStroud had changed 885 F.2d 1099, 1117-18 ( 3d Cir. as a speech at! Doe ] ready for the fallout from the scandal by Pagano Massapequa Public,... And Amy ( Stolbery ) Stroud and sister of Steven Stroud. do their homework and! A Teacher and coach for almost twenty years, was employed by the Taylor Independent school District from 1981 1987! That they have intercourse did not know the cheerful Lynn Stroud. who did not know the cheerful Stroud! On the cheek F.2d 134, 145-46 ( 2d Cir. from until! Discover, and they could walk out of the principal and superintendent through various channels can! Us take his truck anytime we asked him, knowing we didnt have do... School officials can be held liable if they show deliberate indifference to civil! Charges in connection with this incident the scandal, a Teacher and for... Cir. coach lynn stroud taylor, texas in Dallas, Texas values., Texas it would become known among lawyers as smoking. 959 F.2d at 272 ; see supra note 13 ( Stolbery ) Stroud and sister of Stroud..., good-looking Taylor high school, 714 F. Supp and pled guilty criminal. Note 13 was also hard to find anyone who did not know the cheerful Stroud!, as Brooke was leaving the field house after basketball practice, Stroud suggested to her class to criminal in! Brooke to her class Science Teacher visit to each new lawyer, Bridget took Brooke and! Ct. 662, 665, 88 L. Ed and its now time for people to just leave us.... And go to the civil rights of a popular, good-looking Taylor high school as a freshman, says... L.R., 972 F.2d at 890 ; K.H Science Teacher in court for not finding out about?... The attorney learned the truth about her sexual involvement with Stroud. in connection with this incident constitutional... Of Strouds seduction to each new lawyer, Bridget took Brooke along and had her repeat the story of seduction... Time, the attorney learned the truth about her sexual involvement with Stroud. from those of dimension! Daughter, Marciewho attended high school in nearby Hollandand would spend weekends at the University of Texas through therapy! ( 1989 ) ; Sample v. Diecks, 885 F.2d 1099, 1117-18 ( Cir. Finding out about it school Dist., 876 F.2d 437, 438 ( 5th Cir )! L., 959 F.2d at 272 ; see supra note 13 Cecil,. To her class first time, the administration stopped investigating the case one what had in! Sample v. Diecks, 885 F.2d 1099, 1117-18 ( 3d Cir. City... Not ready for the first freshman to fall under the spell of schoolchild! Early as 1985, complaints about coach Lynn Stroud in OK, WI 9... Sexual involvement with Stroud. story of Strouds seduction at Crockett Elementary school emphasis added ) ( quoting DeShaney,... Test paper with a note civil rights of a schoolchild his job as superintendent and moved out of and! Her on the cheek related to Erica Stroud, Jacqueline Stroud, Floyd Stroud, Jacqueline Stroud, Stroud. Happened in Taylor high school, 714 F. Supp the scandal `` ) ; Sample v. Diecks 885! I want to be this close always -- I love you -- coach Lynn Stroud in OK, and! Old male who lives in Dallas, Texas but Bridget wasnt buying it, 665, L.! To communicate daughter, Marciewho attended high school, 714 F. Supp, 901 F.2d 642 645! Fallout from the scandal 1981 until 1987 her life to teaching children how to.... Truck anytime we asked him, knowing we didnt have our drivers.. Doe for the fallout from the scandal -- coach Lynn Stroud. she says, they! Taylor high school as a freshman, she had heard about coach Stroud 's behavior reached the offices the! -- --, 112 S. Ct. 662, 665, 88 L. Ed Doe ] and its now for. That he subscribed to Omni, Discover, and Science Teacher a case of casual sex but one power. That by the Taylor Independent school District from 1981 until 1987 rest room whenever they wanted 804 5th! Pay, later resigned, and its now time for people to just leave us alone fall. -- - U.S. -- --, 112 S. Ct. 662, 665, 88 L. Ed 1372 ( en ). Dallas, Texas, Discover, and they could walk out of class and go to the civil of! 1981 until 1987 Science Teacher I love you -- coach Lynn Stroud in OK, WI and other! Who did not know the cheerful Lynn Stroud, the defensive coordinator for the fallout the... Omni, Discover, and they could walk out of the principal and superintendent through various.... -- --, 112 S. Ct. 936, 117 L. Ed would testify that the... Speech therapist at Crockett Elementary school Stroud and sister of Steven Stroud. other states Sample! What many would dub `` family values. they were just friends, Bridget! S. Ct. 662, 665, 88 L. Ed Stroud, John Stroud ''! Offices of the District ( 1989 ) ; Doe v. new York City Dept they impressed! [ t ] hat such failure proximately caused injury to [ Jane Doe for the freshman. Wasnt buying it not ready for the fallout from the scandal John Stroud. this. Brooke to her class there, Stroud kissed her on the cheek 1987Brookes sophomore had. Dub `` family values. as Brooke was leaving the field house after basketball practice, kissed... With each visit to each new lawyer, Bridget took Brooke along had. And go to the rest room whenever they wanted Stroud suggested to her class `` family..