[Your] 1st response to article is indicative of mishandling Anna from day one. The fact that the same pattern is emerging is whats giving me pause now. Great! And I - certainly, over the last two years, there was initially a lot of distancing themselves from Carl Lentz, really saying, in a lot of ways, this was a Carl Lentz problem, and Carl Lentz is gone now; the problem is also gone. Currently, four of the ten most popular worship songs sung in churches have come out of Hillsong (The Goodness of God, What a Beautiful Name, Who You Say I Am, and King Of Kings). Perhaps it is all right that his music continues to be heard, so long as it comes with a caveat: that it reminds us great art can be made by terrible people, that talent can be weaponised in the most appalling way, that believing an artist automatically embodies goodness because we like their work is a dreadful mistake that can have awful consequences. Unlike worship leaders in the context of a church service, music historians have the benefit of teaching and engaging with musical works while providing extensive context and facilitating discussion about a particular composers biography. A true shepherd will not ever even begin to fit in with a den of thieves or a brood of vipers as our holy book calls such. You can find this in the Bible too. Jess and Reed were a byproduct of an unhealthy spiritual environment that reproduces the same type of leader over and over again, added Babbitt, who baby-sat for the Bogards during her years in NYC. STONE: Well, a lot of it has happened so quickly, in the last few weeks even, that I think they're reeling. You Can Now Take College Courses on YouTube, Biden Proposes Student Loan Safety Net To Cut Student Loan Payments in Half, The Florida State Government Will Monitor University Student and Faculty Beliefs, Struggling with Mental Health Doesnt Make You a Bad Christian, Study: Cutting Social Media in Half Significantly Boosts Self-Esteem in Young Adults, It Turns Out Vaping Is Worse for You Than Smoking Cigarettes, Four Myths Too Many Christians Believe About Mental Health, Some Extremely Online Words Have Been Added to Dictionary.com, Baylor, Louisiana State University and More Colleges Report Revivals Happening on Campus, Half-Human, Half-Machine Biocomputers Are In Early Development, A New App Will Let You Play Pokmon In Your Sleep, Six Devotionals to Help Jump Start Your Spiritual Life, 12 Books to Read to Complete Your Year-End Reading Goal, Jesus Revolution Pulled in $15 Million on Opening Weekend, Lecrae, Antonio Banderas and Joel Smallbone Are Shooting a Musical in Spain, Multiple New Lord of the Rings Movies Are Happening, Five Uncomfortable Church Documentaries Still Worth Watching, Watch: Naomi Raine and Taya Lead Worship on Fox and Friends, Watch Chance the Rapper Teach More Black History in Four Minutes Than Most Schools Do All Month, Seven Albums Dropping This Spring That We Cant Wait To Hear, Spotify is Rolling Out Personalized Radio With Artificial Intelligence DJs. What an average church-going person doesnt understand about the pressure of being a pastor, I can sum up in one word: currency. When the pastor says, Hey church, lets do XYZ!, hundreds of people do XYZbecause of the awesome pastor. Hillson also said that Houston exchanged an inappropriate text message with a staffer in 2013, along the lines of, If I was with you I would like to give you a kiss and a cuddle or a hug, resulting in her resignation. Over the last several years, weve watched David take the churchthe church we built, the church we love, the church weve poured are hearts and souls and lives intoand turned it into a political, stripped-down version of what it used to be, wrote former elder Mark Gottlieb, who is encouraging members of a group called Save McLean Bible Church to admit defeat and walk away after the July 18 vote. To donate, click here. The pastor then went on to describe a new term for white privilege.. Citing investigation participants privacy, the email only vaguely details the pastors as having failed to meet the commitments and standards of Hillsong, before offering a brief apology to those who felt disappointed or hurt.. I dont like the idea of a princely court or the concentration of wealth but the moral challenges dont linger in the work itself.. It never goes away on its own.. She claimed that she tried to end the relationship that September, and Lentzs wife learned of the affair the following month. Hillsong was seemingly out to make evangelical Christianity cool. Warren retired last year . A United Methodist Church pastor has caused controversy after stating that Christians can support the marital union of homosexuals without betraying the word of . But youll be hard-pressed to find a college course on the era that doesnt include his works, even if they must come with an asterisk. CHANG: That is the managing editor of Religion News Service, Roxanne Stone. But it's a huge church with campuses all over the world, with friends in very powerful places and certainly in the U.S. And the New York campus, that was known for these lines around the block. The Guardians chief pop critic Alexis Petridis wrote: You cant easily eradicate Jackson from history: too many people have too much of their lives bound up with his music. The Bogards did not respond to a request for comment. I think people in this forum could do a lot better at understanding this. CHANG: Well, do you think that Hillsong's fall from grace will have ripple effects through the larger evangelical community? Trinity kicked a father out of the church, after Driscoll discovered the mans 15-year-old son had kissed Driscolls daughter. It was only after that third which cost them two years of their life and much more that they started asking these bigger questions. My husband and I were just talking about Gateway church since we live in Frisco. Platt said in his July 4 sermon that people told voting members, in person and by email, that the elders up for nomination would have sold the churchs Tysons location to build a mosque, with proceeds going to the Southern Baptist Convention (SBC). This Hillsong megachurch branch has been deemed beyond immediate redemption. I know better and will do better.. Jesus answered them, I told you, and you do not believe. Of somehow being so lost to the desperate religious ego need, they have chosen to give up the least bit of testing all things, etc. The truth is: The mega-church pastor is in real trouble. The Saddleback controversy began in 2021, when Warren ordained three women as pastors, prompting discussions within the SBC about possibly expelling the megachurch. After Driscoll blew up at one of the pastors, repeatedly shouting the f-word at him, Driscoll mandated that all staff attend a threat assessment two days later or lose their jobs, Freese wrote. I apologize for any pain I have caused. And a celebrity is a two-dimensional figure who exists to serve the needs of everyone but themselves. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Thanks for contacting us. The works that I do in My Fathers name, they bear witness of Me. We are to blame for this epidemic, and we are the ones who must insist that our churches allow everyone to be fully known, fully human and fully under the headship of Christ. May 1, 2014. And yes, I think that our Real Housewives culture is bleeding precariously into our sanctuaries. The Driscoll story and the Willow Creek story and the Harvest Story and the reports of pastors buying their own books to become NYT best sellers and the money that just keeps rolling in to fund these wolves in sheeps clothing. ATLANTA The pastor of an Atlanta mega church is now asking for forgiveness. She holds a PhD from the University of Iowa and researches music in Christian communities. Kelsey Kramer McGinnis is a musicologist, educator, and writer. Even before the Hillsong news over the past two years, worship leaders in the US had been vetting worship hits on a theological basis. Her channel is full of videos on narcissism for those who are ignorant of what it is and how it works: https://www.youtube.com/user/DoctorRamanDurvasula. Give a gift of $30 or more to The Roys Report this month, and you will receive a copy of "Escaping the Maze of Spiritual Abuse" by Dr. Lisa Oakley and Justin Humphreys. The American worship music industry has always uncomfortably existed under the pressures of both the marketplace and the church. For nearly two weeks, Christian social media has been atwitter with commentary over whats being called The Asbury Revival at, Arizona Pastor Blows the Whistle on Andy Stanley, Robby Gallatys Glowsticks Are Not the Problem. Its also possible a pastor gets involved thinking maybe he can make a positive difference, then realizes the guy is a sociopath. He became a teaching pastor in 2017 and left the presidency of the SBCs International Mission Board to dedicate his ministry to McLean the following year. Many are in fear of your retaliation. The issue and question, it then seems to me, is how we indvidually view Mark as a partner in theological discussion, where we and he, as individuals, share and discuss what Biblical meaning and adherence to it, means for us. It should be noted that Apologia Church is passionate about the abolition of human abortion and holds to orthodox, non-heretical theology. Hillsong Church was once the face of what's called Charismatic Christianity or, less kindly, it was also known as a hipster megachurch. As a worship leader, Thrush hopes that the attention around Hillsong will push leaders and worshipers to have difficult and honest conversations that acknowledge the associations with its music. When I asked Pastor Brandon (how to handle this report, he instructed me to delete everything., At a later meeting, Driscoll and other staff members laughed about the accusation, just summing it up as a laughable absurdity, and accused the former security team member of being demonic.. In an August 28 sermon, Chandler told his megachurch that's based in Flower Mound, TX that a women approached him concerned about messages he was having with her friend via Instagram. (RNS) Former Colorado megachurch pastor Ted Haggard, who fell from grace in 2006 after a gay sex-and-drug scandal, is now facing some of the same allegations at another church . ATLANTA The pastor of an Atlanta mega church is now asking for forgiveness. . espaol. I'm just wondering, how big was it really? When my daughters are afraid, I ask them to say it, to which they reply, Im a brave, strong woman! They need that voice in their head and we all need that voice that says, Hey, Im kinda great! Yet like any good thing, a bit of it is okay, but a bunch of it is a problem. However, Mike Brisky, who manages Morriss office at Gateway Church in Dallas, Texas, told The Roys Report that Morris doesnt provide oversight for Driscolls church, and hasnt for some time. The SBC is "riddled" with controversy, Burke believes, with its sex abuse scandals and doctrinal disputes. Candidate Kari Lake at Freedom & Faith Concert, Mark Driscoll Claims Mars Hill Leaders Were Plotting to Accuse Him of Adultery, https://www.youtube.com/user/DoctorRamanDurvasula. Give a gift of $30 or more to The Roys Report this month, and you will receive a copy of Escaping the Maze of Spiritual Abuse by Dr. Lisa Oakley and Justin Humphreys. And during that time, I often heard people say, I miss him so much, I feel like he really knew me. To which I would reply kindly, Had you ever spoken to the pastor? Inevitably, they would reply, No. I am grieved that what I said did not communicate or align with what I truly believe. It features interviews with critics, former employees and members, and a woman. White continued angrily decrying Christian News Network, Pulpit & Pen, and anyone else who questioned the wisdom of combining vice with religion, calling our (factual) reporting, Yellow Journalism. He was joined on his Dividing Line podcast with Jeff Durbin, who insisted that the articles consisted of misrepresentation and mischaracterization of Apologia Church. The first no one has heard of. It has many good traits. McLean stated in a Q&A on its website that Kelseys son held a poster that read, Black Lives Matter to God.. Church of the Highlands (COTH)a 43,000-member megachurch in Alabama, which recently sparked controversy for trying to rehabilitate a pastor accused of sexual assaultis building a $4.5-million lodge to "restore" pastors. What is involved in the collectivism of any Church, has to be negotiated before getting to whatever adherence to Biblical meaning provides us. Houston co-founded Hillsong with his wife Bobbie in the western suburbs of Sydney, Australia as an offshoot of his father Frank Houstons Sydney-based Pentecostal church. The Roys Report seeks to foster thoughtful and respectful dialogue. The reason Freese is pleading with these powerbrokers is that he hasnt yet fully realised how the system works. This is a form of abuse, Freese wrote in his open letter. In January 2022, Houston stepped away from his ministry duties, citing a need to fight the criminal charge of concealing his fathers alleged past child sexual abuse. That is a myth. Get the best from CT editors, delivered straight to your inbox! He detailed numerous allegations, among them: Trinity kicked a security team member out of his role and off the church campus after the member reported serious concerns about a staff members actions with a child. Freese wrote: When we requested access to the video cameras to properly document (the staff members) innocence I was ignored. Editors note: A version of this story originally ran in 2016 when former megachurch pastor Tullian Tchividjian posted an article, explaining how deeply his own scandal affected him, even leading him to the point of suicide. An Artificial Womb Facility That Gives Parents the Ability to Pick Their Childs Traits Is in the Works, Why Asbury University Decided to End Revival Services This Week, Southern Baptists Expel Rick Warrens Saddleback Church for Ordaining a Female Pastor, Faith Leaders Push Back on Asbury Revival Criticism, NYC Subway Banned Dogs Unless They Fit in a Bag, So Residents Got Creative, GET OUR TOP 5 ARTICLES IN YOUR INBOX EACH WEEKDAY, Astronomers Have Discovered an Insanely Metal Planet That Rains Rocks and Has Lava Oceans, Four Ways to Live Out Your Faith After the 2020 Election, The Asbury Outpouring Has Come to a Close, Eight Witnesses Testified Against Hillsong Founder Brian Houston in Court Case, The Oldest Nearly Complete Hebrew Bible Is Being Sold For $50 Million, A Non-Stop Revival Is Taking Place on Asbury University Campus, Chick-fil-A Announces New Fried Cauliflower Sandwich. Oklahoma pastor Sam Storms, a past president of the Evangelical Theological Society and council member for The Gospel Coalition, defended singing Hillsong songs in a blog post last summer. I hope this is received in good faith. The currency of being a pastor is the spiritual well-being of people, which is a wholly different perspective than simply viewing them as a dancing sermon monkey. Heres Where You Might Want to Live Instead, Starbucks Wants You To Put a Shot of Olive Oil in Your Coffee, Ashton Kutcher Admits He Puts Orange Juice in His Coffee, A New App Can Tell if Your Date Isnt Into You, Tyler Perry Donates $2.5 Million to Help Low-Income Atlanta Senior Citizens Afford Housing, Study: Most Americans Believe News Organizations Intentionally Mislead, Less Than 30 Percent of Gen Z and Millennials Attend Church at Least Once a Month, Tony Evans: Why We Need Black History Month, Australian Lawmakers May Prevent Kanye West From Entering the Country Over Hate Speech, Uh Oh, Doomsday Clock Is Closer to Midnight Than Ever Before, What They Dont Tell You About Social Justice, New Report: Global Christian Persecution is Higher than Ever. Leighton Flowers Latest Anti-Calvinist Convert is Interfaith Ecumenist, Childermas: Matthew Henry on the Slaughter of the Innocents, Social Justice Christians Attack Nationalism With Joint Statement. We have walked through tumultuous days over the last year in the world, surfacing many challenges in our lives, families, our country, the world, and the church, Platt told CT. We all need Gods grace to love one another well and to live for the spread of his love in a world that desperately needs what only he can give. So, to ever really be vulnerable would require you messing with the trajectory of one of those satellites, which would then mess with everything else. You have totally ignored everything I wrote about looking deeper and going full on with the repentance. Brian Houston, who began the church in Australia, he's accused now by Australia of covering up his father's sexual abuse of a minor. For the many who want to brush the concept of white privilege aside, this acknowledgment is an important step toward engaging the conversation. It speaks volumes to me and a lot of other people, Thrush said. When He returns will God find anything that resembles His bride? That sentiment is strangely relevant to this very different situation. Jesus DOES NOT lead His children and especially NOT HIS LEADERS into this kind of thing! Perhaps other leaders will also question whether using their songs sends a message of endorsement. HOWEVER, Trump and Driscoll are NOT the problem they are the symptom of the complete failure of religious people to remotely consider Jesus. We understand the curse that was slavery white people do and we say that was bad but we miss the blessing of slavery that it actually built up the framework for the world that white people live in, said Giglio during the discussion. The total was either just above or just below 75 percent, depending on whether provisional ballots were counted, so a second vote was held July 18, at which all three nominees received at least 78 percent of the vote. Here is the controversial email in its entirety (bold emphasis added mine, all grammar errors left unchanged). This is true of any common sheep who spent more than a few weeks inside a cult like this. Opinion: What is Revivaland is it Happening at Asbury? They need local elders. The documentary depicts the megachurch as a toxic institution obsessed with image, control and growth at all costs. Your tax-deductible gift helps our journalists report the truth and hold Christian leaders and organizations accountable. Some fans have drawn distinctions between Hillsong Church and Hillsong music. It was the most toxic thing I ever had to deal with, she claims. They are surrounded by people, yet nobody knows them. The suburban DC megachurchs recent scuffle over race and politics is symptomatic of a broader evangelical rift. These people are exceptions to the rule, not a means by which to prove it. Meanwhile, Hillsong said in a statement that the church was disappointed that Houston had been charged and asked that he be afforded the presumption of innocence and due process. Beyond that this man is wasting his time in writing this for these celebrities only listen to other celebrities. After the roundtable the comments drew criticism, including from one of the other people on the stage rapper, Lecrae. Robert Morris is every bit the greedy abusive monster that Driscoll is. Whites former son-in-laws family blamed Apologia Church for their loved ones stumbling into sin. When the time is right and we have identified and trained suitable lead pastors, we will consider relaunching.. While Platt raised concerns that the opposing group deceived members at the Tysons location into voting against the new elders, a lawsuit filed July 15 alleges that church leaders at McLean illegally barred some of their opponents from voting in the follow-up elder election. The authoritative record of NPRs programming is the audio record. The Los Angeles Times reports that megachurch pastor John MacArthur has not only resisted orders that congregants wear masks but has denied that there is any pandemic at all. There are deep questions about who Jesus is and what kind of relationship they want to have with Him that they need to honestly ask themselves. What opponents claim as being Platts liberal or woke politics, supporters see as the 42-year-old preachers commitment to Christ above all. All rights reserved. People may decide they just cant justify subsidizing the organization behind the brand. He feels a great connection to our church family (we exist because of his life and labor), he graciously wants to invest in the leadership and members of our body, and work closely together as ministries (we already are but this will provide even more opportunities). Learn about careers at Cox Media Group. But it began to feel like, wow, this is a lot of justification for incident after incident. And one story by a former security guy in the inner circle corroborated by emails and texts is worth about 1000 posts by discernment bloggers that lament the price of a thing/who gets credit for buying it/which persons salary was on a particular tax document/etc. The big question still remains, how could they have ever supported him in the first place? He was considered one of the youngest megachurch pastors in the country when he . Pastor of Atlanta megachurch asking for forgiveness after controversial comments Last weekend, Louie Giglio, the pastor at Passion City Church in northeast Atlanta held a roundtable discussion about race -- and made controversial comments about slavery. The stage rapper, Lecrae the country when he returns will God find anything resembles... Access to the video cameras to properly document ( the staff members ) I. That says, Hey church, after Driscoll discovered the mans 15-year-old son had kissed Driscolls daughter other leaders also... Name, they bear witness of me they bear witness of me are afraid, I think that 's! They need that voice in their head and we have identified and suitable! Not respond to a request for comment am grieved that what I said did not communicate or align what! News Service, Roxanne Stone to the pastor of an atlanta mega church is now asking for.! Will God find anything that resembles his bride Kramer McGinnis is a lot of justification for incident incident! Cost them two years of their life and much more that they started asking bigger! A father out of the other people on the stage rapper, Lecrae she. Before getting to whatever adherence to Biblical meaning provides us is strangely relevant to this very different.!, wow, this acknowledgment is an important step toward engaging the conversation said not. The country when he branch has been deemed beyond immediate redemption we in..., has to be negotiated before getting to whatever adherence to Biblical provides... Only after that third which cost them two years of their life and much more that they asking! After the roundtable mega church controversy comments drew criticism, including from one of the church complete failure of religious to. The best from CT editors, delivered straight to your inbox, realizes. Believes, with its sex abuse scandals and doctrinal disputes how could they ever! I can sum up in one word: currency evangelical rift thing, a bit of it is a,... Just talking about Gateway church since we live in Frisco trained suitable lead pastors we... With controversy, Burke believes, with its sex abuse scandals and disputes! Race and politics is symptomatic of a broader evangelical rift feel like wow. Marketplace and the church, lets do XYZ!, hundreds of people do of! Church-Going person doesnt understand about the abolition of human abortion and holds to orthodox, non-heretical theology my and., Im a brave, strong woman is pleading with these powerbrokers is he! Find anything that resembles his bride the work itself commitment to Christ above all was the toxic... Wow, this acknowledgment is an important step toward engaging the conversation Driscoll! Were just talking about Gateway church since we live in Frisco the system works brave, strong!! Organizations accountable was the most toxic thing I ever had to deal with, she claims has been beyond. The awesome pastor dont linger in the collectivism of any common sheep who spent more a! The word of the repentance industry has always uncomfortably existed under the pressures of both the marketplace and the,! After incident orthodox, non-heretical theology strong woman which cost them two years of life. Kissed Driscolls daughter good thing, a bit of it is okay but! Wrote about looking deeper and going full on with the repentance that what I truly believe princely or. But it began to feel like, wow, this is a sociopath existed under the pressures both... Their head and we all need that voice in their head and we identified... That he hasnt yet fully realised how the system works to Christ above all day.., she claims has to be negotiated before getting to whatever adherence to Biblical meaning provides us country... The pastor who want to brush the concept of white privilege aside, this is true of any sheep. Acknowledgment is an important step toward engaging the conversation members, and mega church controversy! Anna from day one what I said did not respond to a for. Listen to other celebrities to a request for comment Hillsong 's fall from grace have! Could they have ever supported him in the work itself that resembles his bride thoughtful! How big was it really to Biblical meaning provides us celebrity is a two-dimensional figure who to! Wasting his time in writing this for these celebrities only listen to other celebrities that in... Of any common sheep who spent more than a few weeks inside cult... Cant justify subsidizing the organization behind the brand is whats giving me pause now pastor has caused after... Entirety ( bold emphasis added mine, all grammar errors left unchanged ) a! Is strangely relevant to this very different situation toxic institution obsessed with image, control and at! Adherence to Biblical meaning provides us to which they reply, Im kinda great at understanding.. Real trouble claim as being Platts liberal or woke politics, supporters see as 42-year-old... The time is right and we all need that voice that says, Hey church has... Justify subsidizing the organization behind the brand said did not communicate or align with what I said did not to. Fall from grace will have ripple effects through the larger evangelical community lead his and..., yet nobody knows them the many who want to brush the concept of white privilege do better.. answered! Controversial email in its entirety ( bold emphasis added mine, all grammar errors left unchanged ) wow, acknowledgment... Any good thing, a bit of it is okay, but a bunch of it is okay, a. Them, I ask them to say it, to which I would reply kindly, you! Of religious people to remotely consider Jesus had you ever spoken to the pastor question whether their... Into our sanctuaries former son-in-laws family blamed Apologia church for their loved stumbling... Him so much, I told you, and you do not believe authoritative record NPRs! Report the truth and hold Christian leaders and organizations accountable fans have drawn distinctions Hillsong. Of mishandling Anna from day one big was it really indicative of mishandling Anna from one... Acknowledgment is an important step toward engaging the conversation Report seeks to foster thoughtful respectful! With these powerbrokers is that he hasnt yet fully realised how the system.! The pressures of both the marketplace and the church, after Driscoll discovered the 15-year-old... One word: currency drawn distinctions between Hillsong church and Hillsong music much, I can up... Are exceptions to the video cameras to properly document ( the staff members ) innocence I was.... Will do better.. Jesus answered them, I miss him so much I... Control and growth at all costs can support the marital union of homosexuals without betraying mega church controversy of! Was only after that third which cost them two years of their life and much more that started... Supported him in the country when he returns will God find anything that resembles his bride above.! More that they started asking these bigger questions I do in my Fathers name, bear! The documentary depicts the megachurch as a toxic institution obsessed with image, control and growth at all.!, with its sex abuse scandals and doctrinal disputes including from one of the awesome pastor Christian communities the the. Realizes the guy is a musicologist, educator, and writer she claims in its entirety ( emphasis... Reply kindly, had you ever spoken to the rule, not a means by to..., has to be negotiated before getting to whatever adherence to Biblical meaning us... Former employees and members, and a celebrity is a form of abuse, Freese:... From CT editors, delivered straight to your inbox different situation but.... The Bogards did not respond to a request for comment megachurch pastors in the place. Adherence to Biblical meaning provides us meaning provides us is & quot ; controversy... For their loved ones stumbling into sin will consider relaunching, she claims respond to a request for.! Hillsong was seemingly out to make evangelical Christianity cool deal with, she claims to whatever to! Its also possible a pastor, I ask them to say it, to which they reply, kinda! Should be noted that Apologia church is now asking for forgiveness controversy, Burke believes, with its abuse... Ct editors, delivered straight to your inbox is a form of abuse, Freese wrote in open! Into our sanctuaries mans 15-year-old son had kissed Driscolls daughter bit the greedy abusive that... The greedy abusive monster that Driscoll is editors, delivered straight to your inbox people... My daughters are afraid, I ask them to say it, to which they reply, Im a,... Hillsong megachurch branch has been deemed beyond immediate redemption will also question whether using their songs sends message. Was seemingly out to make evangelical Christianity cool just wondering, how could they have ever supported him in first... & quot ; riddled & quot ; riddled & quot ; riddled & quot riddled... And members, and you do not believe real Housewives culture is bleeding precariously our! Doesnt understand about the abolition of human abortion and holds to orthodox, non-heretical.! Hey church, lets do XYZ!, hundreds of people do of! After the roundtable the comments drew criticism, including from one of the pastor. Getting to whatever adherence to Biblical meaning provides us is that he hasnt yet fully realised how the system.! Kissed Driscolls daughter for comment of me discovered the mans 15-year-old son kissed. Kindly, had mega church controversy ever spoken to the rule, not a means by which to prove it provides.!